Qualitative Analysis for Chemistry Paper 3: Tests for Cations, Anions and Gases, and How to Write Observations and Inferences
Chemistry · Chemistry Paper 3 qualitative analysis: observation vs inference, tests for cations with NaOH(aq) and NH₃(aq), anion and gas tests, simple organic tests, collecting and drying gases, and a model salt-analysis answer.
Chemistry Paper 3 at a glance
- Question 1, volumetric analysis: burette table, concordant titres, average titre and mole calculations (see the Volumetric Analysis lesson).
- Question 2, qualitative analysis: a Test | Observation | Inference table for cations, anions and gases. This lesson.
- Question 3, general laboratory knowledge: apparatus, collecting and drying gases, separation, simple organic tests.
Command words
- State / Name: a short fact, no explanation ("Ammonia gas").
- Describe: what you see or do, step by step ("A white precipitate formed which dissolved in excess").
- Explain: the reason, usually with "because".
- Deduce / Infer: a conclusion from an observation ("Zn2+ is present").
The golden rules
- Units everywhere: cm3, mol dm−3, g dm−3.
- Burette readings to 2 d.p.: 24.30, not 24.3.
- Observation ≠ inference. The observation is what you see ("white precipitate"); the inference is what it means ("Zn2+ present"). Never write an ion in the observation column.
- "White precipitate" is not enough: always add whether it is soluble or insoluble in excess.
Preliminary tests: colour and heating
Colour of the solution:
- Blue → Cu2+
- Pale green → Fe2+
- Yellow or brown → Fe3+
- Colourless → Cu2+, Fe2+ and Fe3+ are absent
Heating the solid:
- Colourless droplets on the cooler part of the tube → water of crystallisation.
- Brown gas, and a glowing splint is relighted → NO2 and O2, so a nitrate (NO3−) of a heavy metal.
- Gas turns lime water milky → CO2, so CO32− or HCO3−.
- Crackling sound (decrepitation) → typical of Pb(NO3)2.
- Residue yellow when hot, white when cold → ZnO, so Zn2+.
Cation tests with NaOH(aq) and NH₃(aq)
Add each reagent a few drops at a time, then in excess.
- Ca2+: NaOH: white ppt, insoluble in excess. NH3: no ppt (or very slight).
- Zn2+: NaOH: white gelatinous ppt, soluble in excess. NH3: white ppt, soluble in excess.
- Al3+: NaOH: white gelatinous ppt, soluble in excess. NH3: white ppt, insoluble in excess.
- Pb2+: NaOH: white ppt, soluble in excess. NH3: white ppt, insoluble in excess. KI(aq) gives a yellow ppt.
- Cu2+: blue ppt, insoluble in excess NaOH; with NH3 the ppt dissolves to a deep blue solution.
- Fe2+: green ppt, insoluble in excess of either reagent.
- Fe3+: reddish-brown ppt, insoluble in excess of either reagent.
- NH4+: no ppt with NaOH; on warming, a gas turns damp red litmus blue.
Solving the white-precipitate puzzle
- White ppt with NaOH(aq) in drops. Add excess NaOH(aq).
- Insoluble → Ca2+. Dissolves → Zn2+, Al3+ or Pb2+.
- Add excess NH3(aq): the ppt dissolves → Zn2+. Insoluble → Al3+ or Pb2+.
- Add KI(aq): yellow ppt → Pb2+; no ppt → Al3+.
Anion tests
- CO32−: add dilute HCl → effervescence; a colourless, odourless gas turns lime water milky.
- SO42−: add dilute HCl, then BaCl2(aq) → white ppt, insoluble in the acid.
- Cl−: add dilute HNO3, then AgNO3(aq) → white ppt, soluble in excess NH3(aq).
- SO32−: add dilute HCl and warm → a gas with a choking smell turns acidified K2Cr2O7 from orange to green.
- NO3−: warm with NaOH(aq) and aluminium (or zinc) → a gas turns damp red litmus blue (NH3). Or the brown-ring test: FeSO4(aq) then concentrated H2SO4 gives a brown ring at the junction.
Gas tests: always state the test and the result
- H2: burning splint → "pop" sound.
- O2: relights a glowing splint.
- CO2: turns lime water milky.
- NH3: pungent; turns damp red litmus blue; dense white fumes with HCl.
- Cl2: greenish-yellow; bleaches damp litmus paper.
- SO2: choking; turns acidified K2Cr2O7 orange → green.
- HCl: misty fumes; dense white fumes with NH3.
- NO2: reddish-brown; turns damp blue litmus red.
Model answer: salt analysis
Sample X is a white solid.
- X + distilled water: dissolves to a colourless solution → soluble salt; Cu2+, Fe2+, Fe3+ absent.
- + NaOH(aq), drops then excess: white gelatinous ppt, soluble in excess → Zn2+, Al3+ or Pb2+.
- + NH3(aq), drops then excess: white ppt, soluble in excess → Zn2+ confirmed.
- + dilute HNO3 + AgNO3(aq): white ppt → Cl− present.
- Ppt + excess NH3(aq): ppt dissolves → Cl− confirmed, so X is ZnCl2.
Say it like the marking scheme
- Not "it fizzed" but "effervescence; a colourless gas was evolved".
- Not "a white thing formed" but "white precipitate formed".
- Not "it disappeared" but "the precipitate dissolved in excess".
- Not "it smelt bad" but "a gas with a pungent / choking smell".
- Not "blue solution with NH3" but "blue ppt that dissolved in excess to give a deep blue solution".
Simple organic tests
- Alkene (C=C): bromine water is decolourised rapidly (red-brown → colourless); acidified KMnO4 turns from purple to colourless.
- Alkanoic acid (−COOH): NaHCO3 or Na2CO3 gives effervescence; the gas turns lime water milky.
- Alkanol (−OH): a small piece of sodium gives effervescence; the gas gives a "pop".
- Ester formation: warm an alkanol with an alkanoic acid and a few drops of concentrated H2SO4: a sweet, fruity smell.
Collecting and drying gases
- Upward delivery (less dense than air): NH3, H2.
- Downward delivery (denser than air): CO2, Cl2, HCl, SO2.
- Over water (insoluble or slightly soluble): H2, O2, N2.
- Drying agents: concentrated H2SO4 cannot dry NH3 (they react); fused CaCl2 also reacts with NH3; quicklime (CaO) dries NH3 but not acidic gases (CO2, HCl, Cl2).
Separation techniques
- Salt from its solution: evaporation or crystallisation.
- Chalk or sand from water: filtration.
- Ethanol from water: fractional distillation (different boiling points).
- Dyes in ink: paper chromatography.
- Iodine (or NH4Cl) from sand: sublimation.
- Kerosene and water: separating funnel (immiscible liquids).
Practice
- A solution gives a white precipitate with NaOH(aq) that is insoluble in excess. Which cation is most likely present?
- Which reagents are used to test for SO42−?
- A salt dissolves to give a blue solution. Which cation is likely present?
- Brown fumes are given off when a salt is heated. Which anion does it contain?
- Which gas is collected by downward delivery: NH3, H2 or Cl2?
- Salt Y gives a blue solution, a blue precipitate with NaOH(aq) that is insoluble in excess, a deep blue solution with excess NH3(aq), and a white precipitate with dilute HCl and BaCl2(aq). Name Y.
Answers: 1. Ca2+ · 2. Dilute HCl, then BaCl2(aq) · 3. Cu2+ · 4. NO3− (nitrate) · 5. Cl2 (denser than air) · 6. Copper(II) sulfate, CuSO4
Check your understanding
Practise Tests, Ions & Quantitative Chemistry: 10 questions in study mode, with an explanation after each answer.
Start Practice