Biology Alternative to Practical: Specimens, Drawings and Magnification, Food Tests and Classic Experiments
Biology · How Biology Paper 3 asks about specimens, how to draw and calculate magnification, the food tests with their positive results, the classic experiments with their controls, soil water-retention, and the traps that cost marks.
What Biology Paper 3 tests
- Specimens: identify and classify specimens shown as diagrams, and state observable features.
- Drawing and magnification: large, labelled pencil drawings and the magnification formula.
- Food tests and experiments: reagents, positive results, and the control for each experiment.
- Data: read tables and graphs, such as soil water retention or seedling growth.
Specimen questions: feature + what it does
The answer pattern is: a feature you can see, plus what it does for the organism.
- Toad (Amphibia): moist, glandular skin → gaseous exchange through the skin.
- Cockroach (Insecta): three pairs of jointed legs → rapid running to escape predators.
- Tilapia (Pisces): streamlined body → reduces water resistance in swimming.
- Hibiscus flower (dicot): large, brightly coloured petals → attract insects for pollination.
- Maize grain (monocot): fruit wall fused to the seed coat; one cotyledon.
- Bean seed (dicot): two fleshy cotyledons → store food for germination.
Drawing and magnification
- Use a sharp pencil: clean single lines, no shading or colouring.
- Label lines are ruled, horizontal and touch the part, with no arrowheads.
- Give a title and the magnification, e.g. "External view of a bean seed (×2)".
Magnification = drawing length ÷ actual length. It is a ratio, so it has no unit.
Food tests
Always write the reagent, the colour before → the colour after, and the conclusion.
- Starch: iodine solution → brown to blue-black.
- Reducing sugar: Benedict's or Fehling's solution, heat → blue to brick-red precipitate.
- Non-reducing sugar: no change with Benedict's at first; boil with dilute HCl, neutralise with NaHCO3, then Benedict's and heat → brick-red precipitate.
- Protein: Biuret test (NaOH, then dilute CuSO4) → purple / violet; or Millon's reagent → brick-red on heating.
- Fats and oils: Sudan III → red-stained layer; or rub on paper → translucent spot.
Classic experiments and their controls
- CO2 is needed for photosynthesis: a destarched leaf in a flask with KOH, which absorbs CO2. Control: a leaf in a flask with water. The test leaf gives no blue-black colour with iodine.
- Light is needed for photosynthesis: a destarched leaf partly covered with foil. Control: the uncovered part. Only the uncovered part turns blue-black.
- CO2 is given off in respiration: germinating seeds and lime water. Control: boiled (dead) seeds. Lime water turns milky only with the living seeds.
- Osmosis: a potato cup in water. Control: a boiled potato cup. The level rises only with living tissue.
- Transpiration: a potometer, watching the air bubble move. Control: a leafless shoot. Water is lost mainly through the leaves.
Germination experiment
Seeds are set up in four tubes. Only the tube with water, oxygen and warmth germinates well.
- Boiling the water removes dissolved oxygen; a layer of oil stops air dissolving back in.
- The tube with all three conditions is the control.
- Percentage germination = number germinated ÷ total × 100; for example 18 ÷ 20 × 100 = 90%.
Soil water retention
Equal masses of sand, loam and clay are placed in funnels and the same volume of water is poured on each.
- Sand has the largest particles and big air spaces, so water drains through fastest and it retains the least.
- Clay has the smallest particles, so it has the highest water-retaining capacity.
- Loam is best for farming: it holds enough water and air, and drains well.
- Precaution: use the same mass of each soil and the same volume of water.
Exam traps
- Shading or colouring a drawing.
- Arrowheads on label lines.
- Giving magnification with a unit ("×4 cm"): it is a ratio, ×4.
- Writing "iodine turns blue": say brown → blue-black, then conclude.
- Stating a feature that cannot be seen in the specimen.
- Forgetting to name the control and its purpose.
Practice
- A drawing is 8 cm long and the specimen is 2 cm long. Find the magnification.
- Name the reagent used to test for a reducing sugar and its positive result.
- In an experiment to show that CO2 is needed for photosynthesis, what does KOH solution do?
- What is a suitable control for an experiment showing that germinating seeds give off CO2?
- Which soil type has the highest water-retaining capacity?
- A 9 cm drawing is made of a 3 cm insect. What is the magnification?
Answers: 1. ×4 · 2. Benedict's solution, blue → brick-red precipitate · 3. It absorbs carbon dioxide · 4. Boiled (dead) seeds · 5. Clay · 6. ×3
Practise Practical Skills (Alternative to Practical): 10 questions in study mode, with an explanation after each answer.
Start Practice